Skip to main content

Electronic vs Manual Parking Brakes

 A number of items in your vehicle have been replaced by electronics. The parking brake, often known as a handbrake, footbrake, or emergency brake, is one of the elements on the list. It's known as an electronic parking brake by most manufacturers, but it's also known as a drifting mechanism by certain enthusiasts.

In any event, modern vehicles are vastly different. On new vehicles, we're starting to see less mechanical control interfaces, but is advancement truly all that it's cracked up to be? Are we ready to put the mechanical parking brake to rest? Let's look at some of the advantages and disadvantages of both.

Majority of drivers are not aware that a faulty parking brake can cause a MOT test failure. If you check MOT history of your car you can be sure this was a culprit for failure on at least one occasion.

How do parking brake’s function?

If you've ever seen a drum brake in action, you'll understand how the parking brake works. Brake shoes and a piston drive the shoes against the drum walls, locking them in place and causing friction to hold or lock the rear wheels. If you are not sure, search for car services in Reading and speak with a car mechanic if possible for further information.

The driver interacts with a mechanical lever that is connected to the rear brake through a steel cable in manual parking brakes. A ratcheting mechanism secures the lever in place once the pedal is depressed. The location of the lever is determined by the manufacturer's design, and it can be either a footbrake or a handbrake. Handbrakes are more frequent on automobiles, but a footbrake is less common, since it is only seen on automatic cars because the clutch pedal takes up the leftmost area of the driver's footwell, where the footbrake pedal is normally located.

Electronic parking brakes work on the same concept as mechanical parking brakes, but instead of a mechanical lever and cable, the parking brake is activated by a switch, which then engages the electronic motor, allowing the rear brake shoes or pads to contact the vehicle's rear drum or disc.

As mentioned earlier, a faulty parking brake will lead to a MOT failure. Hence it is recommended to check MOT status of your car and have your local mechanic diagnose and repair the issue.

Manual Parking Brake

Advantages

Some enthusiasts would argue that the classic e-brake is the best since it adds another interface to assist control the car, and even non-enthusiasts enjoy the mechanical aspect and feel of the traditional parking brake. Apart from personal taste, manual brakes are simply easier to maintain and fix if something goes wrong, and the lever system is virtually bulletproof due to its simplicity. Parts are readily available, and almost anybody can repair a manual brake, not that there are many to break in the first place.

On the first symptom of a problem with your parking brake, look for a cargarage near me online and schedule an appointment with a skilled expert. A vehicle's parking brake is a vital safety element that should always be in good functioning order.

In an emergency, if your front brakes fail and you need to come to a complete stop, the larger control interface of a manual parking brake will be easier to reach or grip in a hurry. In an emergency, grabbing a lever or depressing a pedal is far easier than looking for a little switch that would allow you to safely come to a halt, and the actuation of a manual parking brake is almost one to one.

Disadvantages

The driver is perhaps the most significant disadvantage of a manual brake. Because there is a human factor involved, there is a danger that if the circumstance demanded it, a frightened emergency brake pull would lock the back wheels, perhaps causing the vehicle to lose control. You must be able to modulate an emergency brake appropriately while using it. To stop from a fast speed, you must be able to regulate and gradually raise the pressure on your back brakes.

There's also the matter of upkeep. Steel cables, such as those used in most parking brakes, do stretch out with time, so you may need to have your parking brake repaired on a regular basis. In order for the rear brake pads to make contact with the disc or drum of the rear braking system, the cable must be tensioned. After a while, you may notice that the cable has to be replaced.

Electronic Parking Brake

Advantages

When compared to a manual parking brake or an e-brake, electronic parking brakes are unquestionably more consistent. Because the operation is performed by an electronic motor, you will have more constant brake engagement that is linked to the ABS system, which means you will be able to keep your car stable if you need to stop quickly. Instead of the conventional ratcheting sound, the brake engages with a lovely whirling sound, which is a subjective plus for some.

Another advantage is that, as compared to a manual parking brake, maintenance is virtually non-existent. You don't have to touch the brake system as frequently now that you have an electronic motor instead of a manual lever and cable, unless anything fails or breaks.

The final two advantages of electronic parking brakes are convenience and feedback. Because it is linked to the car's ECU, you may apply the parking brake, change into gear, and the brake will automatically disengage once the vehicle detects movement. Manufacturers can also include a feature called Auto Brake Hold if an electronic parking brake is included. The braking system engages whenever you come to a halt with the function on, keeping you in place. You can set off without doing a little pedal dance once you give it a little acceleration, much like the automated parking brake.

Finally, the inside has a bit more elegance and cleanliness. While a foot brake can solve this, having a switch in the centre console is far more attractive than having a large lever protruding out, perhaps robbing you of cabin room for your armrest.

Disadvantages

The size of the switch is maybe the most significant drawback of the electronic parking brake. Because it is not as big as a lever or pedal, it may be more difficult to activate the brake in a panic or an emergency scenario. This is due to the fact that the touch target is a small, inconspicuous switch that might be confused for another function in the vehicle's centre console. Furthermore, because it is a departure from the norm, most individuals may be unaware of how an electronic parking brake works in the first place.

The cost of repairing an electronic parking brake system is another downside. If the motor fails or breaks, you'll have trouble finding the correct component from the manufacturer to repair it. Aside from that, replacing the will cost significantly more money. Cables are cheap and tensioning your cable in a manual brake is practically free but repairing a damaged brake motor is costly.

Conclusion

So, which is the better option and are electronic parking brakes worth the money? Yes, to that question.  At least for us, the positives exceed the cons. The electronic brake offers convenience and dependability, as well as safety and consistency, which are essential if emergency stopping is necessary. Furthermore, unlike a typical hand brake, you don't have to adjust your brake cable as often, and it frees up more room in the cabin, allowing manufacturers to create a cleaner-looking interior.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

4 Signs Your Exhaust Pipe Is Weak or Broken

  In their regular operation, internal combustion engines emit what is known as exhaust. After combustion, exhaust gases leave the engine's cylinders and travel through the car's exhaust system before being expelled via the tailpipe. A network of metal pipes makes up the exhaust system, which moves exhaust fumes to the back or sides of the car so they may be safely let out. Even though it has a straightforward design, the exhaust system is crucial to engine performance. According to the online MOT history checker , the emissions test is frequently to blame for a MOT test failing. The typical signs of a damaged exhaust downpipe include an extremely loud or stinky exhaust, issues with the engine's performance, and a dangling or dragging exhaust pipe. Any difficulties with the system or its pipes could make the car difficult to drive. The driver can be made aware of a potential problem by a few indications that are typically produced by a defective or malfunctioning exhaus

Can you fail MOT for no washer fluid?

  Notwithstanding being a straightforward check, such countless individuals bomb a MOT test for having no washer liquid. You ought to routinely check your screenwash level whether or not your MOT test is expected as, particularly in helpless driving conditions, your windscreen can before long become covered and confine your perspective out and about Look for a  garage in Reading  and as per the manufacture’s recommendations, book your car in with a mechanic to have the cabin filter replaced. Can you fail MOT for low petrol? Yes a MOT tester can reject to do MOT test of your car because mechanic need petrol for the MOT test checking exhaust and for running the engine. Should I warm car up before MOT? Heating up the motor before a MOT is one method for forestalling unnecessary degrees of smoke being delivered during testing. The actual fumes will be checked for commotion, and to guarantee any impetuses which were fitted when the vehicle was produced are still set up. Car Ser

What does a full service on a vehicle include?

  Checks during a car service can include the engine oil, oil filter, lights, tyres, bodywork, exhausts, brakes, steering, fluid and coolant levels, suspension and 12V battery How long does a full service last? A full car service is a complete check of the whole car, which should be carried out annually or every 12,000 miles. This service can take around 3 hours to complete Are spark plugs changed in a full car service? A full service usually includes everything apart for any parts specified as requiring replacement in your vehicles servicing schedule, such as fuel filters, spark plugs etc. How far back can you check MOT history ? Records are held for up to 10 years, so you will be able to check a detailed history of the vehicle, including: Its MOT passes and failures. Which parts of the vehicle failed the respective test? How long does MOT status take to update? It can once in a while require as long as 5 days for the MOT expiry date to be refreshed after you present yo